Thanksgiving Pies

Warmth of Handcrafted Pies

Handcrafted Pies

Bring Family Together Bite by Bite


Let us help make your celebration even more memorable with our lovingly handmade pies— we believe your family and loved ones deserve nothing less. To guarantee a pie for your celebration, place your pre-order by 5 PM on Sunday, November 24th.

Make this Thanksgiving effortlessly delicious with a handmade touch from Buttered Up Bakery. Pre-order your pie today and let us be part of your table.

Pecan Pie

$25.95

Indulge in tradition redefined – our Pecan Pie, with its opulent French pastry crust and rich luscious filling ensures each slice a rich, nutty tribute to Thanksgiving comfort.

Pumpkin Pie

$19.95

Creamy, spiced pumpkin filling with a toasty papita topping for the perfect crunch. Cozy fall vibes in every slice!

Caramel Apple Pie

$26.95

Crisp apples, cozy spices, and a buttery crust drenched in caramel goodness. One bite, and you’ll be hooked. 🍏🍂🥧✨

Mini Pie Trio: Pecan, Apple & Pumpkin

$10.95

Three fall flavors, one irresistible bite-sized treat. If you would like an alternative combination of pies (e.g. two pumpkin, one apple), please list your preferences in the Order Notes at checkout.

Cinnamon Roll Croissant x 4

$16.95

Flakey, buttery croissants with a cinnamon-sugar twist, packed cold and ready to warm up Thanksgiving morning. Drizzle on the sauces as you cozy up to watch the parade for the ultimate holiday breakfast treat!

Sourdough Bread

$4.99

Artisanal old-world craft, Sonoran winter wheat, a touch of rye, and plenty of time add rich complex flavor to our 72-hour fermented sourdough. You can taste the love and obsessive attention to detail in every bite.

Butter Croissant

$3.99

Experience pure joy with our fresh, flaky, golden butter croissant. Delightful with every bite!

Billing details

Additional information






Your order

Product
Quantity
Total
Cart Subtotal $0.00
Order Total $0.00
  • Pay securely using your credit card.

Your personal data will be used to process your order, support your experience throughout this website, and for other purposes described in our privacy policy.

Scroll to Top